Well, the time has come that I should speak up. It will be an injustice to my feelings if I don’t do it this time. Yesterday, I wasted around 3 valuable hours of my life reading “The Girl in Room 105” by Chetan Bhagat.
The question is — “Is this the first time I got disappointed by his work?”
The answer is — “No”
“Then why did I do this to myself?”
That’s what I have been thinking of ever since I finished reading the book.
I am one of those strange characters, who started reading pretty late in her life and got into some serious bibliophilism at a later stage. My relationship with books had grown from hatred (when I was a kid) to extreme love (when I discovered the magic of reading). I have reached a point of my life where I am matured enough to distinguish between what is good and what I bad for my reading. Unfortunately, “The Girl in Room 105” falls in none of these categories.

The book started with the murder of a girl Zara who was in a relationship with Keshav. Due to religious differences, they have been unable to handle their relationship in an established manner, resulting in a bitter break up. It so happened that she moved on very well in her life, leaving behind Keshav who has been still stuck up with the lost love, intruding in her life in every possible way even after knowing she was in a relationship with Raghu. One fine night, it is found that Zara has been murdered and Keshav happens to be in the same place after she died which is none other than room 105 of Himadri hostel.
Zara, who has been avoiding Keshav since the last couple of years drops a message and ask him to come to meet her in her hostel room the way they did when they dated each other. When Keshav reaches the place, he finds her cold and strangled to death.
The novel was supposed to be a murder mystery but it went from pin to piano addressing social issues like communal differences, terrorism, drug dealing and what not! My question is, do we really need all the social problems accumulated together to read a simple novel? Don’t we have lots of social issues already going on in the world?
To weave the story further, we have extra characters like Safdar, Farzana, Sikander, Capt. Faiz, Golu, Laxman, Pro. Saxena, Pammi and most importantly an inspector Vikas Rana who’s only interested in his promotion and least bothered about how the murder case is turning up to. Two college boys turned Private Tutors, crack open the complicated murder case where Inspector Rana was just busy enjoying the free Café Lattes of Barista. Are we not taking too much on us by reading such things?
Well, I have no doubt that Mr. Bhagat is an excellent storyteller. He has been writing for years now, even though being highly trolled on social media every time he got his work published. I don’t believe in tagging a book as a “DNR” right away, but I fail to answer the question as to ‘what would be the take away of a reader from this book?’ Covering a series of serious issues there is no specific message that the reader can come up to at the end of the book. Nor we have plain a simple entertainment to while away our time.
The character of Zara, however flawed it is, has been explained so less, that all the efforts made to find out the killer, doesn’t leave any impact to the reader’s mind. In spite of having loads of action, there is hardly any emotional touch given to story apart from the fact that Keshav boozed every night to forget Zara.
Cursing myself while reading, and finishing it only for the sake of not leaving something incomplete, I tell my friend how miserable I feel by the end of the day.
“Why do you read his books in the first place? Didn’t you hate Revolution 2020, Half Girlfriend and One Indian Girl too?” she snapped.
The answer to the question is yes. I did hate Revolution 2020, Half Girlfriend and One Indian Girl as well, then why did I read this one? I search my head for an answer to this for quite some time,
Finally, today morning, the thoughts in my mind, came to rest when I saw the old edition of “Five Point Someone” still in my Kindle device. I remember reading a hard copy of the book then, yet when I owned the Kindle, I bought a copy of this book for my collection. The answer just flashed over my mind.
The reason is none other than the book “Five Point Someone” itself. Yes, it was one of those books that I started reading with. One of those books that had a fresh story that a banker turned writer wanted to narrate. The way the tale of three friends has been narrated in the book is what I have always been looking for in his work ever since.
Unlike all the new Indian authors that came up during his era had developed and grown matured over time in their writing, Mr. Bhagat’s work still lacks that genuine factor that was there in his first work. Needless to say, there was no grave social crisis addressed under the book and yet it won the hearts of so many. Every time I pick a book written by him, I wish to see that banker turned writers’ genuine efforts of story-telling. That’s where Mr. Bhagat is not able to crack it. Over time his work has become more of what people want to read and less of what he’s got to say.
Time is high that he leaves all social issues and focus just on the art of simple writing that he’s good at. I am sure if he writes only for the sake of fulfilling his dreams of being a writer and not for making movies and addressing social issues unnecessarily, we can get back the old magic once again.
It's not an open letter to Chetan Bhagat or a book review of the captioned book. It's just the rantings of a readers’ mind.
No comments:
Post a Comment